IB ESS HL Topic 2 — Ecology Paper 1 & 2 Core idea ~11 min read

Succession and How Communities Change

Leave a car park alone for two hundred years and you will not find a car park. You will find woodland. Ecosystems do not sit still: bare ground gets colonised, the colonisers change the conditions, and those new conditions suit somebody else. That slow handover is succession.

📘 What you need to know

What succession is

Succession is a change in one place across time. That is the difference from zonation, which is a change across space at one moment. If a question mentions “years” or “over time” you are in succession territory. If it mentions “up the shore” or “with altitude” you are in zonation territory.

The key thing to hold onto is this: the organisms themselves cause the change. They are not just passengers waiting for conditions to improve. Lichens break up rock. Dead plants rot down into soil. Roots hold that soil in place. Trees cast shade. Every stage makes the site a bit different, and usually a bit better for something else.

Definition Succession = the orderly change in the species making up a community at a site over time

Primary and secondary succession

The only real difference is your starting line.

Secondary succession is far quicker for two reasons. The soil is already there, so nobody has to spend decades making it. And there is usually a seed bank in that soil, plus roots and fungi that survived, so plants come back within weeks rather than centuries.

Same road, different starting line secondary succession skips the slowest part PRIMARY starts here: no soil at all SECONDARY starts here: soil already present bare rock soil forms grasses shrubs woodland Both end up in the same place. One just takes far longer to get there. Making soil from bare rock can take centuries; a seed bank works in a season.
Soil is the bottleneck. Anything that saves the soil after a disturbance saves the ecosystem hundreds of years of work.

The stages, using bare rock as the example

🧩 From bare rock to woodland

  1. Bare rock. No soil, no water held, big temperature swings, no nutrients. Almost nothing can live here.
  2. Pioneers arrive. Spores of mosses and lichens blow in. Lichens grip the rock and their weak acids slowly break the surface into grains.
  3. The first soil. Pioneers die and rot. That dead organic matter (humus) mixes with the rock grains to make a thin, poor soil.
  4. Grasses and small plants. Seeds land on the thin soil and can now root. Their roots hold the soil so rain does not wash it away, and when they die the soil gets deeper and richer.
  5. Shrubs and small trees. The soil now holds enough water and nutrients for bigger, deeper-rooted plants. They shade out many of the smaller plants.
  6. Woodland. The soil is deep enough for large trees. They become the dominant species and the community stops changing much. This is the climax community.
Every stage builds the soil for the next one the brown band is soil depth Bare rock Pioneers Grasses Woodland no soil thin soil deeper soil deep, rich soil nothing living mosses, lichens grasses, herbs shrubs and trees No stage can arrive until the one before it has built the soil. Deeper soil holds more water and more nutrients, so bigger plants become possible.
Notice that the plants get taller as the soil gets deeper. Height needs roots, roots need depth, and depth is made by whatever died there before.

Why does one stage replace another?

This is the part worth understanding properly, because it turns a list you have memorised into an argument you can write.

First, facilitation. Each community makes the site better for the next one. Lichens create grains of rock and humus. Grasses deepen and bind the soil. Shrubs add shade and shelter. Each group builds the conditions the next group needs.

Then, competition. Once conditions improve, the newcomers are simply better at living there. A tree is a terrible pioneer — it cannot grow on bare rock. But once there is deep soil, a tree beats a moss easily, because it grows tall and takes the light. The pioneers are not killed off by the weather any more; they are shaded out.

Here is a neat way to remember it: pioneers are good at surviving; climax species are good at competing. Early on, survival is what matters, so pioneers win. Later, when survival is easy, competition is what matters, so the big competitors win.

What changes as succession runs

Feature Early stages (pioneer) Late stages (climax)
Soil Absent or very thin, few nutrients Deep, holds water, nutrient-rich
Species diversity Low, only a few tough species High, many niches to fill
Total biomass Low High, stored mostly in wood
Energy flow Simple, short food chains Complex food webs, many links
Nutrient cycling Simple and leaky, nutrients wash away Complex and tight, nutrients recycled
Size of organisms Small Large
Stability Easily knocked back More resistant to disturbance
Why does nutrient cycling get tighter? On bare rock there are few roots and no humus, so rain washes nutrients straight out of the system. In woodland, deep roots catch them, fungi and decomposers return them to the soil, and the same atoms get used again and again. Less is lost, so the system needs fewer inputs from outside.

Worked examples

WORKED EXAMPLE 1

A wildfire burns a pine forest to the ground. Twenty years later there are young trees. State which type of succession this is and explain why it is faster than succession on new lava.

Identify the type Secondary succession — a community was destroyed, but the site was not new ground. Give the reason that scores the mark The soil survived the fire, so the slowest step (making soil from bare rock) has already been done. Add a second reason Seeds, roots and fungi survive in that soil, so plants regrow from the seed bank instead of having to arrive from outside. Secondary; soil and seed bank are already in place Ash also adds nutrients, which speeds up the first few years further.
WORKED EXAMPLE 2

Explain how lichens growing on bare rock make it possible for grasses to grow there later. (3 marks)

Mark 1: what the lichens do to the rock Lichens release weak acids and grip the surface, breaking the rock into small mineral grains. Mark 2: what happens when they die Dead lichens are decomposed into humus, which mixes with those grains to form a thin soil. Mark 3: why that matters to a grass Grass seeds need soil to root in and to hold water and nutrients, so they can only germinate once that soil exists. Rock broken down + humus added = a soil grasses can root in Notice the chain: cause, consequence, therefore. Three linked steps, three marks.
WORKED EXAMPLE 3

Marram grass is the pioneer on coastal sand dunes. Suggest two features that make it suited to that role.

Feature 1: getting water Very long, deep roots reach water far below the dry surface sand, which most plants cannot do. Feature 2: coping with salt It tolerates high salt levels from sea spray, so the salty conditions that kill other plants do not stop it. Bonus point worth adding Its roots trap and hold the loose sand, which stabilises the dune and starts soil building for later species. Deep roots for water, salt tolerance, and it stabilises the sand

💡 Exam tip

⚠ Common mix-up

Up next: What Makes an Ecosystem Stable — why some ecosystems bounce back from a disturbance and others never do.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB ESS tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →