IB ESS HL Topic 7 — Natural Resources Paper 2 HL HL only ~10 min read

Storing Energy in Batteries

Batteries are the piece that makes a renewable grid actually work. They are also dug out of the ground in a handful of countries, using mining that causes real damage. This section is where energy, environment and world politics meet, and examiners love it for exactly that reason.

📘 What you need to know

  • Battery storage means using batteries to store energy for later use, which balances supply and demand.
  • Batteries store surplus renewable energy, giving a reliable supply when wind and solar output is low, and cutting reliance on fossil fuels.
  • Large-scale battery storage is essential for countries trying to move to low-carbon energy systems.
  • Key materials: lithium (lithium-ion cells), cobalt (stability and lifespan) and rare earth elements (performance).
  • Mining these causes land degradation, water contamination and habitat destruction, plus toxic by-products and tailings dam failures.
  • Supply is concentrated: lithium in Australia, Chile and Argentina; over 70% of cobalt from the DRC; rare earths dominated by China.

Why battery storage matters

A battery does one simple thing: it takes electricity now and gives it back later. That small shift in timing solves the biggest weakness of renewable energy.

  • Balancing supply and demand: batteries absorb excess energy from wind and solar and release it when production is low.
  • Reducing carbon emissions: because stored renewable energy covers the gaps, fossil fuel stations do not need to be fired up, so emissions fall.
  • The global energy transition: large-scale battery storage is essential for any country attempting to move to a low-carbon energy system.
WHY A SOLAR GRID NEEDS BATTERIES Solar peaks at midday. People use most electricity in the evening. Power BATTERY CHARGES BATTERY DISCHARGES 00:00 06:00 12:00 18:00 24:00 solar output electricity demand Without storage, the midday surplus is wasted and the evening gap needs gas. The battery moves energy across about six hours. That is the whole job.
This mismatch between when solar generates and when people use power is the reason grid batteries exist at all.
If you can explain this one graph, you can answer almost any battery storage question. The surplus at midday and the shortfall at 18:00 are the two things the battery connects.

What is actually inside a battery

ElementWhat it doesWhere it mostly comes from
LithiumThe core of lithium-ion batteries, used in electric vehicles and renewable energy storageAustralia, Chile and Argentina
CobaltImproves battery stability and lifespanOver 70% from the Democratic Republic of the Congo
Rare earth elementsUsed to boost performance in some battery componentsChina dominates mining and processing

Environmental and social impacts

Mining the key materials

Getting these elements out of the ground is where most of the damage happens:

  • Land degradation — large areas are stripped and left unusable.
  • Water contamination — mining processes release chemicals into surface water and groundwater.
  • Habitat destruction — land is cleared for the mine and its access roads.
  • Toxic by-products from processing these elements, which harm ecosystems and human health.

Tailings dams

Tailings are the waste materials left over after the valuable metal has been extracted from the ore. They are stored behind tailings dams. When one of these dams fails, large volumes of toxic material are released into rivers and onto land at once. This is a low-probability, high-impact risk — the same shape of problem as a nuclear accident, and worth pointing out in an essay.

The uncomfortable link. Every electric vehicle sold and every grid battery installed increases demand for exactly this mining. Cleaner energy in one place creates environmental pressure in another.

Geopolitics: who controls the supply

The elements needed for batteries are concentrated in a few countries. That concentration turns a technical problem into a political one.

THE BATTERY SUPPLY CHAIN AND ITS CHOKEPOINTS The first two stages are controlled by a very small number of countries 1. MINING raw materials 2. PROCESSING refining the ore 3. CELLS battery manufacture 4. USE vehicles and grid Lithium: Australia, Chile, Argentina Cobalt: DRC over 70% China dominates rare earth refining Lithium-ion cells cobalt adds lifespan Electric vehicles and grid storage CHOKEPOINT: a few countries control most of stages 1 and 2 Trade restrictions and export quotas there can disrupt the whole global market Concentrated supply creates dependency, and dependency creates leverage. This is the same energy security argument from earlier, applied to metals instead of fuel.
Notice how closely this mirrors the oil and gas situation. Swapping fossil fuels for batteries changes which countries hold the power, not whether anyone does.

Growing demand

Demand for lithium, cobalt and rare earths is rising rapidly because of the growth of electric vehicles and renewable energy technologies. Rising demand plus concentrated supply is the classic recipe for price spikes and disputes.

Tensions over supply chains

  • Dependency: uneven distribution of resources leaves most countries dependent on a few key suppliers.
  • Political instability: instability in resource-rich regions such as the DRC complicates supply chains and raises the risk of interruption.
  • Trade restrictions and export quotas: particularly by China for rare earth elements, these can disrupt global markets. The USA relies on China for processing rare earths, which has created disputes over trade policy and resource control.

🤔 Why “swapping to batteries” does not remove geopolitical risk

Fossil fuel politics is about controlling a flow: oil has to keep arriving, every week, for ever. Battery metal politics is about controlling a stock: you need the materials once, when the battery is built, and the battery then works for years. So the risk is real but different in shape. A country cut off from cobalt cannot build new batteries, but its existing ones keep working. That is a genuinely better position than being cut off from gas in the middle of winter — and recycling can reduce the dependency further over time. Making that comparison is exactly the sort of evaluation that earns top marks.

EXAM-STYLE

Explain how battery storage helps a country reduce its carbon emissions. [3]

Step 1 — the surplus Wind and solar often generate more electricity than is needed at that moment, and without storage that surplus is wasted. Step 2 — storing it Batteries store the excess renewable energy as chemical energy instead of losing it. Step 3 — the emissions saving That stored energy is released when renewable output is low, so fossil fuel power stations do not need to run to fill the gap, lowering greenhouse gas emissions. 3 marks: surplus, storage, avoided fossil fuel use The mark is for the avoided fossil fuel generation, not for the battery itself. Say that link explicitly.
EXAM-STYLE

Evaluate the claim that battery storage is an environmentally sustainable technology. [6]

Supporting the claim Batteries let renewable energy be used when it is needed, reducing fossil fuel generation and greenhouse gas emissions. They are essential to any low-carbon energy transition, and they have long service lives. Against the claim Mining lithium, cobalt and rare earths causes land degradation, water contamination and habitat destruction. Processing produces toxic by-products. Tailings dams can fail and release toxic material into rivers. Over 70% of cobalt comes from the DRC, raising ethical and supply-risk concerns. Judgement Batteries are sustainable in use but not in production. Overall they are justified because they displace continuous fossil fuel emissions, but only if mining is better regulated and recycling of cells is improved. 6 marks: both sides with evidence, plus a justified conclusion “Sustainable in use but not in production” is a strong one-line framing. Use it and then justify it.

💡 Exam tip

  • Learn the three elements and their jobs: lithium for the cell, cobalt for stability and lifespan, rare earths for performance.
  • Quote the 70% cobalt from the DRC figure. Specific numbers lift an answer immediately.
  • Split your impacts into environmental (mining, water, habitat) and social or political (dependency, instability, trade restrictions).
  • Tailings dams are the detail most students miss. One sentence about dam failure is often a whole mark.
  • Link back to energy security: concentrated metal supply creates the same dependency problem as imported gas.
  • For evaluations, use the life-cycle split — clean while in use, damaging to produce and to dispose of.

⚠ Common mix-up

  • “Batteries are a source of energy.” They store and release energy that something else generated.
  • Assuming batteries are automatically green. The mining and processing behind them cause serious damage.
  • Cobalt and lithium confused. Lithium is the main cell chemistry; cobalt improves stability and lifespan.
  • Forgetting the political side. Distribution of resources and trade restrictions are examinable content, not background colour.
  • Ignoring tailings. Tailings are the waste left after extraction, and the dams that hold them can fail.
  • One-sided evaluations. A question asking whether batteries are sustainable needs both the use phase and the production phase.
That completes 7.2. Up next: What Counts as Waste, the first page of 7.3 Solid Waste — where the same life-cycle thinking gets applied to everything we throw away.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB ESS tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →