IB Psychology HL & SL Topic 9 — Exam Guidance Paper 1 Section C Exam skill ~9 min read

Writing a Strong ERQ in Paper 1

Fifteen marks, one essay, about 35 minutes. Section C is not a memory test — it is a test of whether you can think like a psychologist about a concept. The students who do best are rarely the ones who know the most studies. They are the ones whose essay argues something.

📘 What you need to know

What the marks are actually for

An ERQ mixes two assessment objectives. AO1 is what you know: the theory and the evidence. AO3 is what you do with it: strengths, limitations, counterarguments, applications. Weak essays are all AO1. Strong essays keep both running side by side.

Two things the marker is looking for AO1: KNOWLEDGE AO3: EVALUATION The concept, defined clearly A relevant theory explained Studies used as evidence Accurate terminology gets you into the middle Strengths and limitations A counterargument Ethics, culture, real-world use A judgement you commit to gets you to the top An essay with no AO3 caps low, however much you know.
The commonest high-ability mistake is a beautiful, detailed, entirely descriptive essay. Knowledge without judgement does not reach the top band.

A structure that works every time

A five-part plan for 35 minutes 1. INTRODUCTION Define the concept. State your line of argument. 2. POINT ONE Theory plus evidence, then evaluate it. 3. POINT TWO A second angle, again with evaluation. 4. COUNTER The strongest case against your line. 5. CONCLUSION Answer the question. Say how far, and why. Plan for five minutes. The plan is what stops you writing a list.
Sections 2 and 3 are where AO1 and AO3 sit together. Never separate them into a knowledge half and an evaluation half — evaluate as you go.
A quick way to force evaluation: after every piece of evidence, write “however” or “this suggests” and finish the sentence. Those two connectives drag an essay from describing into arguing almost by themselves.

Using studies properly

The temptation is to write everything you remember about a study. Resist it. In a concept-based essay, a study earns its place by showing something about the concept.

Weak use of a studyStrong use of a study
Full aim, procedure, sample and findingsOne line on what it did, then what it shows
Dropped in with no link to the conceptNamed as evidence for a specific claim
Left unevaluatedFollowed by a strength or a limitation that matters
Three studies making the same pointTwo studies that disagree with each other

The command terms in Section C

Worked example

WORKED EXAMPLE

In the context of human relationships, evaluate the role of bias in social identity theory. [15 marks]

Here is a plan plus one paragraph written out, so you can see the density expected.

Plan 1 Define bias and social identity theory; state the line. 2 In-group favouritism as a bias in behaviour. 3 Bias in how the theory was researched. 4 Counter: other explanations for the same behaviour. 5 Conclusion. Written paragraph — point one with evaluation attached Social identity theory explains bias as a product of belonging: once people categorise themselves into a group, they compare it favourably with others to protect self-esteem, which produces in-group favouritism. This is a genuine strength of the theory, because it explains discrimination without needing any real conflict of interest between the groups. However, much of the supporting evidence comes from artificial group tasks with young male participants, which raises questions about how far the effect transfers to real relationships where group membership carries history and consequence. Conclusion to aim for Bias is central to what social identity theory explains and also present in how the theory was tested, so the concept is both the theory’s subject and one of its limitations. Concept defined, applied, evaluated, judged Notice the conclusion says something. “In conclusion, there are strengths and limitations” says nothing.

💡 Exam tip

⚠ Common mix-up

Up next: Writing a Strong SAQ in Paper 2 — the four questions about your own class practical, and how to prepare for all of them at once.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB Psychology tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →

Subscribe to our newsletter

Get free IB notes, exam tips and new resources in your inbox.

We will ask you to confirm by email. Unsubscribe any time.