IB ESS HL Topic 2 — Ecology Paper 1 & 2 Core idea ~8 min read

Why Energy Is Lost at Each Level

Nothing like 100% of a trophic level’s energy reaches the level above it. There are four separate leaks, they happen in a fixed order, and if you can name all four in that order you can answer almost any question on this topic.

📘 What you need to know

The four leaks, in order

Follow a caterpillar eating the leaves of an oak tree and each leak becomes obvious.

🧩 From leaf to caterpillar biomass

  1. Not all the food is harvested. The caterpillars do not reach every leaf — there may be too many leaves, too few caterpillars, or leaves in places they cannot get to.
  2. Not all of what is harvested is eaten. They may eat only the softer, more nutritious parts and leave tough sections or parts containing toxins.
  3. Not all of what is eaten is absorbed. Some of the leaf is indigestible, so it passes through and is egested as faeces.
  4. Not all of what is absorbed is stored. Much of the energy is released in respiration and lost as heat rather than being built into new tissue.
Where a trophic level’s energy goes Four leaks between one level and the next FOOD AVAILABLE EATEN ABSORBED STORED not eaten roots, bones, out of reach faeces indigestible material heat and urine respiration and excretion Only what is stored as new biomass can be passed upwards Roughly a tenth survives all four steps in a typical chain
Each red arrow is energy leaving the food chain. Only the green box on the right is available to the next trophic level.
A quick memory hook: reached, eaten, absorbed, stored. Four words, four losses, in the order the food actually travels.

Which loss is biggest?

Respiration. Every organism has to keep itself alive — moving, breathing, transporting substances, staying warm if it is a bird or mammal. All of that costs energy that is released as heat and never becomes body tissue.

That is why warm-blooded animals are especially inefficient. Maintaining a constant body temperature is expensive, so a smaller fraction of what a mammal eats ends up as new biomass compared with, say, an insect.

Egestion or excretion? Egestion is undigested material leaving as faeces — it was never absorbed. Excretion is waste from metabolism, such as urea in urine — it was absorbed and then used. Examiners notice when students swap these.

Why it limits food chain length

Because roughly nine tenths leaks away at each step, the energy remaining shrinks fast. After four or five transfers there is simply not enough left to support another population of predators, which is why most terrestrial ecosystems have no more than five trophic levels.

WORKED EXAMPLE

Rabbits in a field have access to 46 000 kJ m−2 yr−1 of grass. They eat 11 000, egest 3 400 in faeces, and lose 6 800 as heat from respiration. Calculate the energy stored as rabbit biomass.

Step 1: Start from what was eaten, not what was available 11 000 kJ enters the rabbits Step 2: Add up the losses after eating 3 400 + 6 800 = 10 200 kJ Step 3: Subtract 11 000 − 10 200 = 800 800 kJ m−² yr−¹ stored The 46 000 figure is a distractor – most of it was never eaten
WORKED EXAMPLE

Explain why a food chain based on cattle supports fewer people than one based on wheat, using the same area of land.

Step 1: Count the trophic levels wheat → human is one transfer wheat → cattle → human is two transfers Step 2: Apply the losses Each extra transfer loses roughly 90% as heat, faeces and uneaten material Step 3: State the outcome Far less energy reaches people through the longer chain This is the energy argument for plant-based diets

💡 Exam tip

⚠ Common mix-up

Up next: Biomass and Productivity — how we actually measure the energy stored at each level, and what gross and net productivity mean.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB ESS tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →