IB ESS SL 3.1 Biodiversity & Evolution Paper 1 & 2 Core idea ~13 min read

How Evolution Generates Diversity

Every species alive today is the result of the same simple process running for billions of years: more offspring are born than can survive, they are not all identical, and the ones that fit their surroundings best leave the most young. That is it. Everything else is detail.

📚 What you need to know

What evolution is

Definition Evolution is the cumulative change in the heritable characteristics of a population or species over time.

Two words in there are doing heavy lifting. Cumulative means it is the overall change built up over many generations, not one dramatic event. Heritable means it only counts if it can be passed on — a scar or a suntan changes an individual but changes nothing about the next generation.

Biodiversity, all three levels of it, is what this process has produced. Natural selection has been running for billions of years, and it has not stopped.

Natural selection, step by step

🧩 The sequence that fits every example

  1. Individuals in a species show variation, caused by differences in their genes.
  2. Organisms produce more offspring than the environment can support.
  3. This causes competition for food, space, mates and other resources — a struggle for survival.
  4. A selection pressure acts. Individuals whose characteristics are best suited have a higher chance of surviving to reproduce.
  5. Those individuals pass on their genes at a higher rate than the less well suited ones.
  6. In the next generation, a greater proportion carry the advantageous characteristic. Repeat for many generations and it becomes the norm.

Learn this as a sequence rather than as a set of facts. Whatever organism a question gives you — a moth, a bacterium, a plant, a fish — the same six steps apply and you only have to change the nouns.

One round of natural selection same population, one generation later one generation red cross = eaten before breeding before: mixed population after: more dark formsThe individuals best suited to the environment leave the most offspring. Nothing changes inside an individual. The proportions in the population change.
Some pale moths survive on the right-hand side. Selection shifts the odds; it does not guarantee anything for any single individual.

A worked example: moths on darkened bark

That last bullet is the one people skip. There is no such thing as a permanently “better” characteristic. An advantage exists only in relation to a particular environment, and environments change.

A second example: antibiotic resistance

This is natural selection you can watch in real time, and it is the clearest evidence that the process is not something that finished in the past.

Three things to be careful about. Better-adapted organisms are more likely to survive, not certain to. Less well-adapted organisms can still survive and breed, just at lower rates. And every organism experiences selection pressure, not only animals — plants, fungi and bacteria all do.

Where variation comes from

🧠

Easy way to remember it

Mutation proposes, selection disposes. Mutations arrive by chance and are not aimed at anything. The environment then decides which of them get passed on.

Speciation

Definition Speciation is the generation of new species through evolution, when populations become isolated and adapt to their environments in different ways until they can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring.
How one species becomes two isolation, then divergence, then no more interbreeding 1 ONE POPULATION 2 SEPARATED 3 TWO SPECIES barrier they can interbreed gene flow stops cannot interbreedSeparation, then different selection pressures, then two separate species. The test is simple: can they still breed and produce fertile young?
The barrier can be a mountain range, a sea, a river or a stretch of unsuitable habitat. What matters is that genes stop moving between the two groups.

The sequence

  1. A population becomes isolated into two groups that no longer breed with each other.
  2. The two environments impose different selection pressures.
  3. Different characteristics are favoured in each group, so they diverge over many generations.
  4. Eventually the differences are large enough that the two groups cannot interbreed to produce fertile offspring.
  5. At that point they are counted as separate species.
The definition of a species that ESS uses is about fertile offspring, and that word matters. A horse and a donkey can produce a mule, but mules are sterile, so horses and donkeys stay two species.

Worked examples

WE 1

Explain natural selection in an example

A population of insects is sprayed with a pesticide each year. Explain how the population becomes resistant. (4 marks)

Step 1: variation The population shows genetic variation, and by chance a few individuals carry a mutation giving resistance. Step 2: selection pressure The pesticide is the selection pressure. Non-resistant individuals are killed, resistant ones survive. Step 3: reproduction Survivors reproduce and pass the resistance gene on at a much higher rate than the rest. Step 4: the outcome Over generations the frequency of the resistance gene increases until most of the population is resistant. Variation, pressure, differential survival, changed gene frequency say the mutation existed before the spraying — the pesticide selects, it does not create resistance
WE 2

Explain speciation

Explain how a single species can give rise to two separate species. (4 marks)

Point 1: isolation A population becomes split, for example by a mountain range or a sea, so the two groups no longer interbreed and gene flow stops. Point 2: different pressures The two environments impose different selection pressures, so different characteristics are favoured in each. Point 3: divergence Over many generations the gene frequencies in the two populations become increasingly different. Point 4: the threshold Eventually they can no longer interbreed to produce fertile offspring, so they are classed as separate species. Isolate, diverge, and at some point the two can no longer breed the word “fertile” is not optional; without it the definition is incomplete
WE 3

Correct a misconception

A student writes: “The moths turned darker so they could hide on the sooty bark.” Explain why this statement is wrong. (3 marks)

Point 1: individuals do not change An individual moth cannot change its colour in response to its surroundings; its colour is determined by its genes. Point 2: the variation was already there Both pale and dark forms already existed in the population before the bark darkened. Point 3: what actually happened Darker moths survived predation more often and reproduced more, so the proportion of dark individuals in the population increased. The population changed. No individual moth changed. avoid words like “wanted”, “tried” or “in order to” — they imply organisms choose to adapt

💡 Exam tips

⚠ Common mistakes

Up next: Measuring Biodiversity — you can describe diversity in words all day, but conservationists need a number they can compare.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB ESS tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →