IB Biology HL Climate Change Paper 1 & 2 ~9 min read

Carbon Sequestration

Two pages of bad news, and now the useful bit. If ecosystems can be turned into carbon sources by human activity, they can also be turned back into carbon sinks – and the biology of how that works is straightforward, even if the politics is not.

📚 What you need to know

What sequestration means

Scientists think global warming can be slowed by increasing carbon sequestration. The definition is short, so learn it word for word.

Definition Carbon sequestration is the process of capturing and storing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere.

In practice this means increasing the amount of carbon moving out of the atmosphere and into natural carbon sinks. There is hope that artificial carbon storage will become viable at some point, but you should be clear in an exam that it is still at the research stage. Everything usable today is biological.

Moving carbon out of the air and into a store ATMOSPHERIC CARBON DIOXIDE photosynthesis locks carbon into wood incomplete decay carbon stays in the peat dissolving into surface water FORESTS carbon held in biomass PEAT BOGS carbon held in dead matter OCEANS carbon held in solution ARTIFICIAL CARBON STORAGE – still at the research stageEvery one of these arrows can be run backwards by damaging the sink.
These are the same sinks that appeared on the causes page. Protecting them and building them up is the whole of natural sequestration.

Forest regeneration and afforestation

Two words that sound similar and mean different things, so get them straight now.

TermWhat it means
Forest regeneration (reforestation)Planting new trees in areas that have been deforested – putting forest back where forest used to be
AfforestationThe creation of new forest in an area that did not previously have it

The biology behind both is simply photosynthesis running for a long time. If trees are allowed to grow to maturity, they can store huge amounts of carbon in their biomass. The carbon that was carbon dioxide in the air ends up as cellulose and lignin in the trunk, and it stays there for as long as the tree does.

Costa Rica is the example to quote: the country now plants around seven times as many trees as it cuts down, which shows that lost forest really can be restored. It is worth adding the honest caveat, because examiners like it – achieving this needs large government inputs, usually in the form of payments and benefits to landowners. Trees are cheap; persuading people not to clear land is not.

Peat bog restoration

To understand why peat bogs matter, you have to understand why the plant matter in them never finishes decomposing.

Peat forms when dead plant matter cannot decompose fully, because the ground is waterlogged – and therefore anaerobic – and acidic. Decomposers cannot work properly in those conditions, so the plant material only partly breaks down and accumulates as peat, year after year. The carbon locked into that partly decomposed matter is what makes peat bogs an essential carbon sink. Peatlands form in boreal and temperate ecosystems, and can form rapidly in tropical ones.

Human activity releases that store in two main ways. Peat is harvested for fuel, and bogs are drained so the land can be used for development or agriculture. Both routes return carbon to the atmosphere – the first by combustion, the second by decomposition.

The draining part is worth thinking about carefully. Bogs are drained by digging drainage ditches so the land dries out. As the peat dries, the waterlogged anaerobic conditions disappear, and the activity of decay organisms increases. The bog does not need to be dug up to lose its carbon; it just needs to be dried.

The whole thing turns on where the water sits Raise the water table and the decomposers stop working again.DRAINED PEAT BOG water table CO₂ released dry peat above the water decay organisms become activeRESTORED PEAT BOG water table carbon stored waterlogged and acidic decomposition stays incompleteFilling in the ditches is enough. The bog does the rest by itself.
A drained bog is not a neutral piece of ground – it is actively leaking carbon that took thousands of years to accumulate.

Restoration is therefore about water, not planting. Filling in drainage ditches and regulating peat harvesting allows bogs to recover and to continue growing in depth, which increases their ability to sequester carbon.

Notice the pattern. Both sequestration methods on this page work by restarting a natural process that human activity had interrupted – photosynthesis in one case, incomplete decomposition in the other. Neither invents anything new. That is exactly why they are described as naturally occurring ecosystem processes.

NOS: an argument scientists are still having

Scientists do not always agree on the best way to do something, and different approaches can bring different benefits and different problems. Carbon sequestration by tree planting is a live example, and the syllabus expects you to be able to present both sides fairly.

ApproachThe argument for itThe trade-off
Plantations of non-native treesFast-growing species sequester the maximum mass of carbon in the shortest time, which matters if the goal is to slow warming quicklyA plantation is not a natural ecosystem, so the benefit for biodiversity is limited
Rewilding with native speciesEncouraging native species restores naturally occurring ecosystems, which is likely to be better for biodiversityCarbon is sequestered more slowly, so the climate benefit arrives later
In a NOS question you are not being asked which side is right. You are being asked to show that you understand why reasonable scientists can look at the same goal and disagree about the method. Give both positions, name the trade-off between them, and stop there.

Worked examples

WE 1

Define and apply

Define carbon sequestration, and outline how forest regeneration increases it. (3 marks)

Step 1: the definition Carbon sequestration is the process of capturing and storing carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. Step 2: what regeneration is Forest regeneration means planting new trees in areas that have been deforested. Step 3: the mechanism Those trees take in carbon dioxide by photosynthesis and, if allowed to grow to maturity, store large amounts of carbon in their biomass. Photosynthesis moves carbon from the air into wood, and holds it there the phrase “grow to maturity” is doing real work – young trees store far less
WE 2

Explain why peat stores carbon

Explain why peat bogs act as carbon sinks, and how draining them releases carbon dioxide. (4 marks)

Point 1: the conditions Peat bogs are waterlogged, and therefore anaerobic, and acidic. Point 2: why that stores carbon Decomposers cannot function properly in these conditions, so plant matter only partly decomposes and the carbon in it accumulates as peat. Point 3: what draining does Digging drainage ditches allows the peat to dry out, removing the waterlogged anaerobic conditions. Point 4: the release Decay organisms become active, decomposition proceeds, and respiration by these organisms releases carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. Carbon is stored by decomposition failing, and released when it restarts say both “anaerobic” and “acidic” – one on its own usually only earns half the credit
WE 3

Evaluate two approaches

Outline the scientific debate over whether non-native plantations or rewilding with native species is the better approach to carbon sequestration. (3 marks)

Point 1: one position Some scientists favour planting fast-growing non-native trees, because these sequester the maximum mass of carbon in the shortest time. Point 2: the other position Others favour rewilding, encouraging the growth of native species so that naturally occurring ecosystems are restored. Point 3: the trade-off Rewilding sequesters carbon more slowly, but is likely to be more beneficial for biodiversity. Speed of carbon capture against ecosystem quality present it as a genuine disagreement between scientists, not as one side being wrong

💡 Exam tips

⚠ Common mistakes

Up next: Climate Change & Phenology – how warming knocks the timing of biological events out of step, and why a caterpillar peaking two weeks early is bad news for a nest full of chicks.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB Biology tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →