IB Physics HL Topic 3 — Oscillations & Waves Paper 1 & 2 An expanding universe ~16 min read

Redshift of Galaxies

Point a telescope at a galaxy and measure its spectral lines. Red-shifted — it’s running away. Fine. Now point it somewhere else. Red-shifted. And again. And again. If galaxies were milling about at random you would expect roughly half to be coming towards us. Almost none are. Something is very wrong with the picture of a static universe — and putting it right meant accepting that space itself is stretching.

📘 What you need to know

Redshift and blueshift

You met this last page for a single star. Now apply it to the whole sky.

Redshift, defined the fractional increase in wavelength (equivalently, the fractional decrease in frequency) caused by the source and observer receding from each other

It is a fraction, so it has no units. Numerically it is the same Δλ/λ you used last page, and for slow galaxies it equals v/c.

Positive and negative velocities

Exam questions ask for a velocity, not just a speed, so the sign carries meaning. Using the frequency form Δf = f0f:

ObservationΔfVelocity relative to EarthShiftMotion
f0 > fPositivePositiveBlue-shiftApproaching Earth
f0 < fNegativeNegativeRed-shiftReceding from Earth
Careful — and this catches almost everyone. Work in frequencies and a red-shift gives you a negative velocity. Work in wavelengths and the very same red-shift gives a positive Δλ. The two forms carry opposite signs, because longer wavelength means lower frequency. So never decide the direction from the sign alone. Ask instead: did the wavelength get longer? Then it is receding. Say it in words, and you cannot go wrong.

The evidence: spectra of ever more distant galaxies

Line up the spectra of a lab source, a nearby star, and galaxies at increasing distances. The pattern of lines is identical in every one — same elements, same fingerprints. But the further away the object, the further the whole pattern has slid towards red.

The further away, the bigger the redshift lines shift this way → very distant galaxy distant galaxy nearby galaxy nearby star laboratory reference 400 500 600 700 wavelength / nm
Same three lines every time — that is how we know it is the same element. Only the amount of the shift changes, and it grows with distance.

An expanding universe

Almost every galaxy is receding from us. That sounds suspiciously as though we are at the centre of some cosmic explosion. We aren’t. The resolution is stranger and better: the space between the galaxies is expanding.

The balloon

Draw dots on a balloon and inflate it. Every dot moves away from every other dot. No dot crawls across the rubber — the rubber grows between them. Stand on any dot you like and all the others recede from you.

Dots on an inflating balloon inflate before after the orange gap has grown — and so has every other gap
The dots (galaxies) never move across the rubber. The rubber (space) stretches between them. Pick any dot as home and every other dot recedes.
The balloon is a two-dimensional universe: everything lives on the surface, and there is no centre on that surface to point to. That is the honest answer to “where did the Big Bang happen?” — everywhere at once. Don’t look for the middle of the balloon; you’d have to leave the surface, and there is nowhere to go.

Distance and redshift go together

Measure the redshift of lots of galaxies and also work out how far away each one is. Plot one against the other and the points fall on a straight line through the origin.

Redshift against distance redshift distance to the galaxy a straight line through the originfurther away → bigger redshift → receding faster
The most distant galaxies are the most red-shifted, and so are running away the fastest. Exactly what a uniformly stretching space predicts.
Space
expands
stretches
the light
Longer λ
redshift
and more so
if further
Distant galaxies
recede fastest
Why almost, not all? A few nearby galaxies — Andromeda, for one — are blue-shifted. They are close enough that their own motion under gravity beats the gentle expansion of the small amount of space between us. Expansion wins only over very large distances.

🌌 Reading a galaxy’s motion

  1. Compare λ0 with λ (or f0 with f). Longer wavelength, or lower frequency → red-shift.
  2. Get the speed from v = cΔλ/λ, or v = cΔf/f.
  3. Check v/c is small — otherwise the equation doesn’t apply.
  4. State the direction in words: red-shift → receding, blue-shift → approaching.
  5. Bigger redshift? Then it is further away and receding faster.
WE 1

A spectral line has a frequency of 6.170 × 10¹⁴ Hz measured in a laboratory. The same line, in light from a distant galaxy, is measured at 6.152 × 10¹⁴ Hz. Calculate the velocity of the galaxy relative to Earth and state whether it is approaching or receding.

Step 1 — find the change in frequency Δf = f₀ − f = (6.152 − 6.170) × 10¹⁴ Δf = −1.8 × 10¹² Hz Step 2 — use Δf/f ≈ v/c v = cΔf/f = (3.00 × 10⁸) × (−1.8 × 10¹²) / (6.170 × 10¹⁴) v = −8.8 × 10⁵ m s⁻¹ Step 3 — interpret the sign Negative velocity, and f₀ < f, so the light is red-shifted. receding at 8.8 × 10⁵ m s⁻¹ Step 4 — check the equation was allowed v/c = 0.0029, safely << 1. The minus sign is doing real work here: it tells you the direction. Quote the speed as a positive number, then say “receding”.
WE 2

Galaxy A has a redshift of 4.0 × 10⁻³. Galaxy B has a redshift of 1.2 × 10⁻². Calculate the recession speed of each, and state with a reason which galaxy is further from Earth.

Step 1 — redshift is Δλ/λ, so v = c × redshift vA = (3.00 × 10⁸) × (4.0 × 10⁻³) vA = 1.2 × 10⁶ m s⁻¹ Step 2 — repeat for B vB = (3.00 × 10⁸) × (1.2 × 10⁻²) vB = 3.6 × 10⁶ m s⁻¹ Step 3 — which is further? B has the greater redshift, so it recedes faster. Redshift increases with distance, so galaxy B is further away B’s redshift is 3× A’s, so it recedes 3× as fast — and on a straight-line graph through the origin, that puts it 3× as far away.
WE 3

A student says: “Nearly all galaxies are red-shifted, so the Earth must be at the centre of the universe, with everything flying away from us.”
Explain what is wrong with this reasoning, using the balloon model.

Step 1 — what redshift really tells us Every galaxy is receding from every other galaxy, not just from Earth. Step 2 — the balloon Dots on an inflating balloon all separate. Stand on any dot and all the others recede from you. Step 3 — the key idea The dots do not move across the rubber. The rubber stretches between them — space itself is expanding. Step 4 — conclude no special centre; every observer sees the same thing An observer in any galaxy would also record almost everything red-shifted, and would be just as tempted to think they were at the middle.

💡 Top tips

⚠ Common mistakes

Quick recap: Redshift is the fractional increase in wavelength (or decrease in frequency) when a source and observer recede from each other; blueshift is the reverse. Comparing galaxy spectra with a lab reference shows almost every galaxy is red-shifted, and the more distant the galaxy, the greater the shift and the faster it recedes. The explanation is not that we sit at a centre, but that space itself expands between the galaxies — the dots on an inflating balloon.
We have squeezed a great deal out of light. Now let’s go back to sound, where the source moves through a medium at a decent fraction of the wave speed — and the neat approximation Δλ/λv/c no longer does the job. Sound needs its own exact equations, one for a moving source and one for a moving observer. That’s the last page of this sub-section.

Redshift and the expanding universe not clicking?

Book a free meeting and we’ll work through redshift calculations, the balloon model and past-paper questions together.

Book your free meeting