IB Biology SL Topic 3 — Ecological Niches & Nutrition Paper 1 & 2 Core idea ~12 min read

Competition Between Species

There is the niche a species could occupy, and the niche it actually gets. The gap between the two is filled entirely by other living things — and that gap is what this page is about.

📚 What you need to know

The niche, one more time

A niche is the role of a species within its habitat. That role takes two kinds of interaction into account:

Fundamental and realised niche

Fundamental niche The full range of conditions and resources in which a species could survive and reproduce, based on its adaptations and tolerance limits.
Realised niche The actual conditions and resources in which a species exists, due to biotic interactions.

The difference is caused by other organisms. On its own, a species can live anywhere its physiology allows. Add competitors and predators, and it gets squeezed into whichever part of that range it can hold on to.

The barnacle example

The barnacle Chthamalus dalli has a wide fundamental niche. It can attach to a variety of substrates across a wide range of rocky intertidal areas in the Pacific Northwest, and it tolerates a broad range of temperature and salinity.

In reality its realised niche is much smaller, because it competes with another barnacle, Balanus glandula, for space and resources. Its actual range is restricted to areas where Balanus is absent or scarce — higher up the shore, where it is exposed to air for longer periods and can avoid the competition.

Where it could live, and where it does Same shore, same barnacle — the only difference is a competitor high tide low tide Chthamalus high tide low tide Chthamalus BalanusFUNDAMENTAL NICHE where it could live with no competitors the potential distribution, and it is largeREALISED NICHE where it actually lives, with competitors the actual distribution, and it is smallerNothing about the rock changed. Only the neighbours did. Chthamalus survives high up because it tolerates being out of water for longer.
The upper shore is harsher, not better. Chthamalus is not choosing it — it is the only stretch where Balanus cannot follow.
Fundamental nicheRealised niche
The niche a species would occupy if there were no limiting factors and it could use every resource availableThe niche a species actually occupies in the presence of competitor species
The potential distribution of a speciesThe actual distribution of a species
No competition for resources, and no predationCompetition for resources and predation both occur
LargeSmaller
A quick way to keep them straight: fundamental is what the body can do; realised is what the neighbours allow. The species has not changed at all between the two panels — only its company has.

Competitive exclusion

A niche can only be occupied by one species, which means every species has its own unique niche. If two species try to occupy the same one, they compete for exactly the same resources, and something has to give.

🧩 The three possible endings

  1. One species out-competes the other, and the loser is forced into a new, slightly different niche.
  2. One species out-competes the other, and the loser is made locally extinct.
  3. Both species are pushed into a smaller part of their fundamental niches, and both persist in reduced form.

The elimination of a competing species from its niche — ending 2 — is called competitive exclusion.

The Paramecium experiment

The classic demonstration uses two species of single-celled, free-living protozoans: Paramecium aurelia and Paramecium caudatum.

Two species, two cultures, two very different outcomes Nothing changed except whether they shared the flaskGROWN SEPARATELY GROWN TOGETHER P. aurelia P. caudatum P. aurelia P. caudatum eliminated0 4 8 12 16 0 4 8 12 160 50 100 population density time / daysBoth can live there. Only one of them gets to. The shape of the caudatum curve is the whole result: it rises, then loses.
Grown apart, both species thrive. Put them in one flask and P. aurelia out-competes P. caudatum for the same resources, until P. caudatum is eliminated.
An important caveat. This experiment was done under laboratory conditions, where both species were deliberately given identical resources. In nature it is rare for two species to occupy exactly the same niche — which is precisely why complete exclusion is rarely seen in the wild.

🤔 So why does the world not end up with one species per habitat?

Because outcome 1 and outcome 3 are far more common than outcome 2. Competition usually pushes species apart rather than wiping one out: each ends up specialising on the resources it happens to be better at.

Go back to the warblers in the spruce tree. The most likely reason each species feeds in its own band is exactly this — competition pushed them into slightly different niches, and now they coexist. What looks like peaceful sharing is the fossilised result of an old fight.

Worked examples

WORKED EXAMPLE

Distinguish between the fundamental niche and the realised niche of a species. [3 marks]

Step 1: the fundamental niche The full range of conditions and resources in which the species could survive and reproduce, based on its adaptations and tolerance limits. Step 2: the realised niche The conditions and resources in which it actually exists, given the biotic interactions it faces. Step 3: the distinction The realised niche is always smaller than the fundamental niche, because competition and predation exclude the species from part of the range it could otherwise occupy. Potential vs actual, with the reason for the difference The word “biotic” is doing real work here. The difference is caused by other organisms, not by conditions.
WORKED EXAMPLE

Using the graphs above, describe and explain what happens to P. caudatum when it is grown with P. aurelia. [4 marks]

Step 1: describe, using the data Grown separately, P. caudatum rises and levels off at a density of about 78. Grown together it rises to only about 32 by day 4, then falls steadily to almost zero by day 16. Step 2: explain the fall The two species occupy the same niche in the culture, so they are in direct competition for the same resources. Step 3: name what is happening P. aurelia obtains resources more successfully → fewer are left for P. caudatum → its death rate exceeds its birth rate → the population falls Competitive exclusion: P. caudatum is eliminated “Describe and explain” means data first, biology second. Quote figures off the graph in the describe part.
WORKED EXAMPLE

Chthamalus can survive across the whole shore in the laboratory, but on a real shore it is found only high up. Explain this. [3 marks]

Step 1: identify which niche is which The whole shore is its fundamental niche, since its tolerance limits allow it to survive there. The upper shore is its realised niche. Step 2: name the biotic factor On a real shore it competes with Balanus for space and resources, and Balanus out-competes it on the lower shore. Step 3: explain why the upper shore is different Higher up, the rock is exposed to air for longer. Chthamalus tolerates that better, so Balanus is absent or scarce there and cannot exclude it. Out-competed low down; survives high up because its competitor cannot

💡 Exam tip

⚠ Common mix-up

That completes Ecological Niches & Nutrition. The through-line: a niche is a role, the role is mostly about food, and where two roles overlap too far, one species gives way.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB Biology tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →