IB Economics HL Topic 2 — Demand Paper 1 & 2 Diagram skill ~10 min read

What Shifts a Demand Curve

A price change slides you along the demand curve. Everything else picks the curve up and moves it. Getting this distinction right is probably the single most examined skill in the whole of microeconomics — and it is also where most marks are quietly lost.

📚 What you need to know

What a shift looks like

Hold the price completely still. If people now buy more than before, the curve has moved right. If they buy less, it has moved left. The price did not have to change at all for this to happen.

SHIFTS OF THE DEMAND CURVE Same price, different quantity: the whole curve has moved PRICE ($) D₂ D D₁ INCREASE IN DEMAND DECREASE IN DEMAND P Q₂ Q Q₁ QUANTITY Right means more is bought at every price. Left means less.
Notice the price line never moves. That is the whole point of a shift: the change happens at every price, not because of a price.

The five non-price determinants

DeterminantWhat happensWhich way the curve moves
Real incomePeople can afford more (or less) at every price. For normal goods the link is directIncome up → right. Income down → left
Tastes and preferencesFashion, health news, advertising and branding change what people wantMore popular → right. Less popular → left
Price of a substituteA rival good gets dearer, so buyers switch to this oneSubstitute’s price up → right for this good
Price of a complementA good used alongside this one gets dearer, so fewer of both are boughtComplement’s price up → left for this good
Number of consumersPopulation size or the age profile of the market changesMore buyers → right. Fewer buyers → left
Future price expectationsIf buyers expect prices to rise, they buy now instead of laterExpect a rise → right now. Expect a fall → left now
Six rows for five determinants, because substitutes and complements are two halves of the same idea (“prices of related goods”). Learn them as separate rows anyway — questions almost always ask about one or the other, not both.

Inferior goods: the exception on income

For most things, a rise in income means more demand. These are normal goods. But some goods are bought precisely because money is tight — supermarket own-brand food, long-distance coach travel, second-hand clothing. When incomes rise, people trade up and buy less of these. They are inferior goods, and their demand curve shifts left when income rises.

Inferior does not mean bad quality. It is a statement about how demand responds to income, nothing else. A perfectly good product can be an inferior good.

Substitutes and complements

RELATED GOODS PULL IN OPPOSITE WAYS One good replaces the other, or the two are used together SUBSTITUTES Price of tea rises Demand for coffee rises the two move the SAME way COMPLEMENTS Price of printers rises Demand for ink falls the two move OPPOSITE ways Substitutes replace each other. Complements are used together.
Ask yourself: would I buy one instead of the other, or one along with the other? That question sorts every related-goods question you will ever get.
Watch the direction carefully. It is the price of the other good that changes, and the demand for your good that shifts. Nobody moved along the coffee curve in that left-hand column — the coffee curve itself moved right.

Movement or shift? The test that always works

TWO DIFFERENT THINGS, TWO DIFFERENT NAMES Only a price change moves you along the curve MOVEMENT ALONG the price changed quantity demanded changes SHIFT OF THE CURVE something else changed demand changes at every price
Left: one curve, two points. Right: two curves. If your diagram has only one curve on it, you cannot be describing a shift.

🧩 The two-question test

  1. What caused the change? If the answer is “the price of this good”, stop — it is a movement along.
  2. If it was anything else, it is a shift. Now ask: at the old price, would people buy more or less?
  3. More → shift right, an increase in demand. Less → shift left, a decrease in demand.
  4. Then say it properly: “demand increases from D to D₁” for a shift; “quantity demanded extends” for a movement.

Worked examples

WORKED EXAMPLE 1

For the market for domestic flights, state whether each causes a movement along or a shift, and in which direction: (a) airlines cut fares; (b) train ticket prices double; (c) a recession cuts household incomes; (d) an airport tax on passengers is scrapped, lowering ticket prices. [4]

Ask each time: was it the price of flights, or something else? (a) Price of the good itself → movement along, extension in QD (b) Price of a substitute rises → shift right, demand increases (c) Income falls, flights are a normal good → shift left, demand decreases (d) Ends as a lower ticket price → movement along, extension in QD along, right, left, along (d) is the trap. The tax changes supply, but what consumers respond to is the lower price, so they move along their curve.
WORKED EXAMPLE 2

Using a diagram, explain the effect on the demand for electric cars of a large fall in the price of home charging units. [4]

Step 1: identify the relationship Charging units and electric cars are complements — used together. Step 2: apply the rule The price of the complement falls, so owning an electric car becomes cheaper overall. Step 3: state the shift At every price, more electric cars are wanted: demand shifts right, D to D₁. Step 4: the diagram Two parallel downward-sloping curves, the second to the right, with an arrow and both curves labelled. Complement cheaper → demand for the other rises → shift right Do not also move the supply curve. The question only changed something on the demand side.
WORKED EXAMPLE 3

Incomes in a country rise sharply. Explain what happens to the demand for supermarket own-brand instant noodles. [3]

Step 1: classify the good Own-brand instant noodles are typically an inferior good. Step 2: state the relationship For inferior goods, income and demand move in opposite directions. Step 3: conclude with the shift Richer households trade up to fresh or branded food, so demand shifts left. Income up → demand for an inferior good falls Add a caveat: whether a good is inferior depends on the country and the income level, so this is not automatic.

💡 Exam tip

⚠ Common mix-up

Up next: The Law of Supply and the Supply Curve — the same logic seen from the seller’s side of the counter.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB Economics tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →