IB Biology HL Ecosystem Stability & Change Paper 1 & 2 ~12 min read

Stability in Ecosystems

Parts of the Amazon have been rainforest for tens of millions of years. Nothing external has been propping it up for all that time, which means the system must be doing something right internally. This page is about what that something is – the four things an ecosystem needs in order to keep going on its own.

📚 What you need to know

What a stable ecosystem looks like

Stable ecosystems share a set of features, and they are all connected to each other rather than being a random list.

The definition to use Stability in an ecological context means resistance to change – the ecosystem carries on functioning in much the same way even when conditions vary.

The rainforest example

Some tropical rainforests, such as the Amazon in South America and the Congo in Africa, have remained in their current state for tens of millions of years. What keeps them going is worth breaking down, because it is really the four requirements in action:

The forest supplies itself with both water and nutrients Neither loop needs anything delivered from outside the ecosystem. CLOUD transpiration falls as rain dead leaves fall SOIL DECOMPOSERS nutrients released here are taken up again by the roots
Both loops close inside the forest. That is the whole reason a rainforest can sit in the same place for millions of years.
Healthy ecosystems are highly stable, but they are not entirely static. Natural selection is always acting on the species within them, so evolutionary change continues even in an ecosystem that looks unchanged from the outside. Stability is about the system, not about the individual species in it.

The four requirements for stability

An ecosystem needs all four of these. Take one away and the whole thing starts to unravel, which is why exam questions often give you a scenario and ask which requirement has been broken.

Four things every stable ecosystem needs Two are about supply. Two are about coping with change. A SUPPLY OF ENERGY usually sunlight, converted into chemical energy by photosynthesis RECYCLING OF NUTRIENTS decomposers return minerals to the soil, so the supply never runs out GENETIC DIVERSITY enough different alleles for natural selection to have something to act on CLIMATE WITHIN TOLERANCE temperature and rainfall staying inside the limits species can surviveRemove any one of these and the ecosystem stops being self-supporting.
When a question describes a damaged ecosystem, work out which of these four boxes has been broken. That is usually the mark scheme.

1. Supply of energy

A reliable source of energy must be present, and for most ecosystems that source is sunlight. Light energy is converted into chemical energy by photosynthesis, which means plenty of photosynthetic organisms – plants or algae – have to be present. The stored chemical energy is then passed up food chains through consumption.

2. Recycling of nutrients

For an ecosystem to support itself, nutrient cycling is essential. If nutrients are not recycled, the supply simply runs out.

Nutrients are cycled when decomposers such as bacteria and fungi break down the carbon compounds – proteins, nucleic acids and the rest – in the tissues of dead organisms and in waste matter. Two things are released:

Producers then take these up again and they re-enter the food chain. Note the condition attached: the ecosystem must have conditions that suit the decomposers. There needs to be enough oxygen and moisture, and the temperature must be suitable. An ecosystem that is too hot or too dry will have reduced nutrient cycling and will therefore be less productive.

Where humans break this one. If nutrients are physically removed from an ecosystem, the cycle is interrupted and productivity falls. Two everyday examples: fallen trees taken away for timber instead of being left to decompose, and crops being harvested. In both cases the nutrients leave the system in the back of a lorry and never come back.

3. Genetic diversity

Genetic diversity is one aspect of diversity, and it has a specific definition.

Definition Genetic diversity is the number of different alleles of genes present in a population.

High genetic diversity means natural selection has favourable alleles to act on, which gives a population the potential to adapt when the environment changes. The reverse is the point worth writing down: if a population has only a limited number of alleles, the chance that one of them happens to be favourable in the new conditions is reduced, and the population will be unable to adapt.

That is why genetic diversity allows populations to resist the effects of change in their environment – which is exactly what stability means.

4. Climatic variables within tolerance limits

Genetic variation only takes a population so far. If extreme environmental changes occur, conditions may move outside the tolerance limits of a species altogether. The climatic variables in question are things like temperature and rainfall.

Once conditions are outside its tolerance limits, a species must migrate or face extinction – the same two options that appeared in the climate change unit. And this is where the two topics join up: human activities are causing climate change at such a rapid rate that climatic variables in some ecosystems are already changing beyond tolerance levels.

🧠

Energy in, nutrients round, alleles ready, climate steady

Four requirements, four short phrases. Energy in – a reliable input. Nutrients round – cycled, not imported. Alleles ready – enough genetic diversity to adapt. Climate steady – variables inside tolerance limits.

Worked examples

WE 1

Outline the features of a stable ecosystem

State three features that are typical of a stable ecosystem. (3 marks)

Any three of the following Efficient nutrient cycling, so the system is self-supporting; high biodiversity; resistance to change, for example consumer population sizes staying roughly constant; high levels of photosynthesis. Cycling, diversity, resistance, photosynthesis “it does not change” on its own is not enough – say what stays constant and why
WE 2

Explain the role of decomposers

Explain why the activity of decomposers is essential for the stability of an ecosystem. (4 marks)

Point 1: what they do Decomposers break down the carbon compounds in dead tissue and waste matter. Point 2: what is released Carbon is released as carbon dioxide and minerals such as nitrates and phosphates are released into the soil. Point 3: the return Producers take these nutrients up again, so they re-enter the food chain rather than being lost. Point 4: why it matters Without this recycling the supply of nutrients would run out and the ecosystem could not support itself. Decomposers are what make the system self-supporting you can add that decomposers need suitable oxygen, moisture and temperature to work
WE 3

Apply the idea of genetic diversity

A population of plants has very low genetic diversity. Suggest why this population is less likely to survive a change in climate. (3 marks)

Point 1: the definition Genetic diversity is the number of different alleles present in the population. Point 2: the consequence With few alleles, the chance that any one of them is favourable under the new conditions is reduced. Point 3: the outcome Natural selection therefore has little to act on, so the population cannot adapt and may not survive if conditions move outside its tolerance limits. No variation means nothing for selection to work with selection does not create useful alleles – it can only favour ones that are already there

💡 Exam tips

⚠ Common mistakes

Up next: Ecosystem Stability (Skills) – the two practical skills attached to this topic. How to build and run a mesocosm, and how to calculate percentage loss when an ecosystem is being cleared.

Want this explained one-to-one?

Book a free session with an experienced IB Biology tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.

Book a Free Session →