IB Business Management SLTopic 5 — Operations ManagementPaper 1 & 2Core idea~9 min read
Deciding Where to Produce
Two bakeries can sell the same bread, at the same price, made by equally good bakers — and one of them still closes within a year. Very often the difference is where they set up. Location quietly changes what a business pays out every month and how many customers can actually reach it. And once the lease is signed, it is slow and expensive to undo.
📚 What you need to know
Location affects both sides of profit: the costs a business pays and the revenue it can earn.
The main pulls are: nearness to the market, to materials, to labour, to competitors, plus infrastructure and the type of business.
Some factors can be turned into money (quantitative). Others cannot (qualitative) but still decide the answer.
Heavy, bulky materials pull the site towards the supplier. A heavy, bulky finished product pulls it towards the customer.
No site wins on everything. A business picks the best overall fit and then lives with the trade-off.
Location is a long-term, expensive-to-reverse decision, so it is taken at senior level.
Why location is worth this much fuss
Think of location as a decision that gets paid for every single month, forever. Rent, wages, delivery charges and utility bills all depend on where you are. So does the number of people who walk past the door.
That gives you a simple way to think about any location question. Ask two things:
What does this site do to our costs? Cheap land far from everything can save on rent and lose it all again on transport.
What does this site do to our revenue? A busy high street costs more, but more customers see you.
The best site is not the cheapest one. It is the one where the gap between revenue and costs is biggest.
Students often write “location is important because rent is cheaper”. That is only half a mark’s worth. Push it one step further: cheaper rent lowers fixed costs, which lowers the break-even point, which means the business survives on fewer sales. Cause, consequence, therefore.
The six things pulling the decision
Every location question in the exam is really one of these six, dressed up in a story about a company.
Teal boxes tend to pull towards suppliers and the nature of the job; amber boxes pull towards people, markets and links. Most real decisions are a tug of war between them.
Nearness to the market
How far is the business from the people who buy from it? Being close cuts delivery costs and makes it easy for customers to turn up. For a coffee shop or a hairdresser this is almost the whole decision — a service you have to walk into has to be where the walkers are.
Nearness to labour
Some jobs need people with particular skills. A software firm needs coders; a hospital needs nurses. Setting up where those people already live means you can hire faster and pay less to attract them. Set up in the wrong place and you end up paying a premium just to persuade people to move.
Nearness to materials
If the raw materials are heavy, awkward or perishable, every kilometre costs money. A fruit-juice bottler wants to be near the orchards, not three countries away with fruit going soft in a lorry.
Nearness to competitors
This one cuts both ways, which is exactly why examiners like it.
Move towards them if customers like to compare before buying. That is why car dealerships and furniture shops cluster on the same road.
Move away from them if you would just be splitting the same customers. A second corner shop on a quiet street helps nobody.
The nature of the business activity
What the business actually does sets the shape of the site it needs. A factory needs floor space, power and room for lorries to turn. A law firm needs a smart, easy-to-reach office and almost no space at all. Same city, completely different shortlist.
Infrastructure
Infrastructure means the things around the site: roads, rail, ports, airports, power supply and internet. A next-day delivery business near a motorway junction can promise things a rural site cannot. An online business with slow internet cannot function at all.
Do not forget government. Grants, tax breaks and enterprise zones are often used to attract businesses to areas with high unemployment. Free money changes the maths, but it is usually short term — a smart answer says the grant may not last.
Which way does the pull go?
Here is a rule that decides a lot of factory locations, and the sort of thing that turns a decent answer into a strong one.
Ask yourself: what is heavier and bulkier — what goes in, or what comes out? Whichever is more expensive to move, the factory moves closer to it.
Sugar refining and timber mills sit next to their materials because most of what arrives is waste. Fizzy drinks and furniture are bottled or assembled near the customer, because air and water are cheap to add locally and expensive to ship.
A neat test in the exam: if the finished product is mostly water, gas or air (drinks, bread, sofas), the plant will be near the market. If most of the raw material gets thrown away during production (ore, cane, timber), the plant will be near the supplier.
Numbers and judgement
Location factors split into two groups, and a good answer uses both.
Quantitative — you can price it
Rent or purchase price of the site
Wage rates in the area
Transport and delivery costs
Local taxes, grants and subsidies
Expected sales revenue at that site
Qualitative — you have to judge it
Reputation of the area and how it fits the brand
Quality of life for staff, and staff willingness to move
Political and legal stability
Room to expand in five years’ time
Ethical view of moving jobs away from a community
Watch out for the trap. The cheapest site on paper is often the worst overall. A site that saves $2,000 a month in rent but sits an hour from every customer can lose far more than that in missed sales.
WORKED EXAMPLE
Comparing two sites on cost
Kalim is choosing a unit for his furniture workshop.
Site A: rent $4,000 per month, delivery cost $3.00 per item. Site B: rent $6,500 per month, delivery cost $1.20 per item.
He expects to make and deliver 2,000 items a month.
(a) Which site is cheaper? (b) At what output would the two sites cost the same? [4 marks]
(a) Work out the total monthly cost of each siteSite A = 4,000 + (3.00 × 2,000) = 4,000 + 6,000 = $10,000Site B = 6,500 + (1.20 × 2,000) = 6,500 + 2,400 = $8,900Site B is cheaper by $1,100 a month(b) Set the two costs equal and solve4,000 + 3.00q = 6,500 + 1.20q1.80q = 2,500q = 2,500 ÷ 1.80 = 1,388.9About 1,389 items per monthBelow roughly 1,389 items Site A wins; above it Site B wins. So the “right” site depends on how much Kalim actually sells — which is a forecast, not a fact.
🧩 How to answer a location question
Read what the business does. A service business, a heavy factory and an online seller need completely different things.
Pick two or three factors that actually matter here. Do not list all six — depth beats coverage.
Do any maths the case gives you. If there are numbers in the stimulus, the examiner wants them used.
Add one qualitative point the numbers miss, such as staff, brand image or room to grow.
Decide, and say what it depends on. “Site B, provided output stays above 1,400 units” scores far better than “Site B.”
💡 Exam tip
Always link a factor to costs or revenue. “Near the motorway” is a description. “Near the motorway, so delivery costs fall and same-day delivery becomes possible” is analysis.
Use the case study’s own words. If the stimulus mentions perishable stock or skilled technicians, that is the examiner telling you which factor to pick.
Recommendation questions need a judgement. Choose a site, justify it, and add the condition it depends on.
Mention that the decision is long term. Leases, buildings and equipment make it slow and costly to reverse — that is a strong evaluation point.
If there are numbers, show every step with units and a dollar sign. Method marks are given even when the final figure is wrong.
⚠ Common mix-up
Listing factors instead of applying them. Six one-line bullets score less than two well-explained points tied to the business in the case.
Assuming cheap always wins. Low rent in a remote spot can cost more overall in transport and lost sales.
Confusing “near the market” with “near the materials”. Market means customers. Materials means suppliers.
Treating a government grant as permanent. Grants usually run for a fixed period; the rent does not.
Forgetting the workers. A perfect site with nobody able to staff it is not a perfect site.
Ignoring room to grow. A unit that fits today can trap a business that doubles in size next year.
Up next: Outsourcing, Offshoring and Reshoring — what happens when a business decides that part of the work should not be done in-house at all.
Want this explained one-to-one?
Book a free session with an experienced IB Business Management tutor and get your trickiest topics made simple.
